Newarke Street Again

Take5 Banner

Same Office - New Role

I got in touch with the manager at Newarke Street DHSS office and asked to be re-employed. The previous useless manager and his brown-nosing acolyte Luddie had retired and the BNP supporter had moved on. I sincerely hope that Luddie caught Parrot Fever or was pecked to death by his budgerigars.

I started on 15 October 1976 and reported to a decent and professional HEO named Peter who led the team responsible for visits to claimants and who later became an office manager - and I am sure a good one. I returned as a Clerical Officer but within a few months was once again promoted to Executive Officer.

The area serviced by the office included a large chunk of the City of Leicester, that part of Leicestershire around Melton Mowbray and as far as Bottesford on the border with Nottinghamshire, and the former county of Rutland. It incorporated large council estates, some of the areas of the poorest privately rented terraced housing in the city and beautiful rural villages.

NELeicestershireMap
Map of Northeast Leicestershire [135]
RutlandMap
Map of Rutland [135]

Visiting

DHSS visited benefit claimants for two reasons:

  • To check that information provided on claim forms was accurate
  • To look for special requirements and welfare needs

Instructions on conducting visits were contained in the 'V' code, but I have doubts about how many visiting officers read it.

Visiting Officers were trained using a variation of the 'sitting with Nellie' method I mentioned earlier. To start with, a new officer would accompany an experienced one to see how it was done, then they would do visits accompanied by an experienced officer and finally be set loose on the public.

From time to time a senior manager or someone from the Regional Office would do accompanied visits to ensure that the correct procedures were being followed. A good visiting officer needed to know the benefit rules, know the right questions to ask to elicit the required information, be able to deal with people of all kinds and from all walks of life, be able to handle angry and mentally ill people, and to be very astute.

Most visits were to retired people to confirm that their circumstances hadn't changed and to check for any extra benefit additions needed due to their health. We would also check whether they needed clothing or other essentials and that they were in touch with a relative or friend. Most visits were straightforward and very civilised, but you needed to get people to focus on the business at hand rather than recounting their life stories. Some pensioners didn't see anyone from one week to the next and would take up a whole morning if you let them. I can see the irony of this as I am writing part of my own life story right now - well at least you can scroll down or quit the page! Very few pensioners were demanding, and most were reluctant to ask for anything extra. The greatest needs, then and now, were with people having young children.

During a typical week I would spend one day driving around the rural part of the area, covering over 100 miles and interviewing about 15 people, the next day assessing and completing follow up actions, and the other three days visiting claimants in Leicester. The rural visits were the most enjoyable, particularly driving around the villages of Rutland with its limestone cottages and front gardens with aubretia cascading over the walls in the Springtime. It was more challenging to drive around a rural area with single-track roads in Winter when it was snowing and you had to guess where the edges of the road were. I had a few close calls but never ended up in a ditch.

Aubretia
Aubretia on a limestone garden wall [137]

I have studied Ordnance Survey maps since learning about them in Geography lessons at school and have built quite a large collection of them over the years. They were an essential tool in locating claimants in rural areas during my visiting days, long before satellite navigation systems had been invented. In searching for obscure places on the map, I came across abandoned canals and drove roads and made time to investigate them on my travels. Drove roads or 'green lanes' long preceded canals and railways and were the routes over which drovers took livestock to markets in towns and cities. The need for droving increased as more and more people moved into cities during the industrial revolution. Drove roads were wide and grassy and the animals could feed as they progressed along them. Sewstern Lane was particularly interesting and forms the boundary between Leicestershire and Lincolnshire for many miles.


The Department introduced an efficiency initiative called 'Management by Objectives'. In our case the objectives were to visit people, complete claim forms and correctly assess their benefit. In other words, do our job. The issue was that the number of successfully completed visits varied, with a minority of visiting officers missing calls or pretending people were out. Claimants were given two days' notice of visits by post in most cases and would usually be at home. There was a standing joke about one member of staff 'knocking on the doors with a sponge' which earned him the nickname 'sponge-man'.

Under the new system, visiting officers completed control sheets that recorded the types of visits made, whether they were successfully carried out and the distances travelled. We were paid a fixed rate per mile depending on the engine size of your car. In my opinion the new system was fair and generally successful.

Transport

My first visits were made in the old Morris Minor PRO 791 acquired from my friend Pete, but it was getting ancient by then and had holes in the floor. This was tolerable in the Summer but not so good driving around the countryside in the Winter as water would squirt up my leg. The car originally had a pathetic 803cc engine, but I replaced this with a 1200cc one to give it more power and, more importantly, claim a higher rate per mile on expenses.

MorrisMinor
A pristine preserved split-windscreen Morris Minor [138]

The heater in the Moggie was defective and after a while I bought a red Mark I Ford Contina from 'sponge-man'. It had been written off after a collision, but the only damage was to one of the front wings which my welder/car mechanic friend Rob replaced. The replacement wing was blue but I wasn't worried about that.

Mark1FordCortina
Mark 1 Ford Cortina [68]

The Cortina had the luxury of a working heater and was watertight. One day, on a visiting round in the heart of Winter, the gear lever snapped off in my hand due to the extreme cold, leaving the car stuck in second gear. I have not heard of that happening before or since and presume there must have been a manufacturing weakness. I limped along to a local car breaker's yard using the clutch and accelerator and got hold of a replacement lever which I quickly fitted and carried on with my visits.

The Mark I Cortina didn't last long, and I had several more cars over the following years which I drove into the ground. The next was a Mark II Cortina that my father-in-law, who was a coach painter, hand painted so it had a finish like a Rolls-Royce. This was followed by a yellow Ford Capri, a silvery-gold Capri and an Opel Rekord estate - all purchased from Rob who seemed to have access to an inexhaustible supply of cheap second-hand cars.

I loved the stylish look of the Capri, and they had 1600cc engines that allowed me to tow a caravan. I started a long career of blocking the roads with 'sheds on wheels' in 1983 when we moved to a house in Barwell with space to store one. The Opel was a real bargain, but the engine was knackered. With Rob's help, I removed the engine, stripped it down, had it rebuilt professionally and reassembled it - my first estate car and the first with a 2000cc engine.

YellowFordCapri
My yellow Ford Capri [71]
OpelRekord
My Opel Rekord Estate car outside my mother's house in Heston [71]

Claimants

Most visits were straightforward and just required diligently going through a standard information-gathering process but a few left impressions that have stayed with me for nearly 50 years. The first group of these are really variations on what passed for 'normal', but the second I have grouped together under the heading 'Problem Cases' for reasons that will be obvious as you read them.

The DIY Dentist

My first visit was to a Mr. Jex. I thought it a very strange name, possibly of Romany origin, but it appears to be a variation on the name Jacques according to genealogy websites. There was a noble family with the name Jex in the North Riding of Yorkshire when the Domesday Book was compiled in 1086. If this man was a descendant, the Jex family fortunes had somewhat declined since the time of the Normans.

The address recorded was the name of a farm which turned out to be in the back of beyond to the north of Melton Mowbray at the end of a long muddy track which took some time to locate on my Ordnance Survey map. I asked the farmer whether Mr. Jex was at home. He told me to go round to the farmyard and look for an ancient taxi; Jex lived in it.

I spotted the taxi between some farm buildings and could see that he slept on the back seat and had a little cooking stove on the passenger side next to the driver's seat where old taxis used to place luggage. A dilapidated rubber tube led through the window to a propane gas bottle outside and looked very dangerous.

It was a damp day and Mr. Jex was standing near the taxi with blood running down his chin. He said he had a toothache and had been pulling a tooth out with a pair of pliers. His teeth were mainly rotting stumps. I told him he could get free dental treatment, but he was not interested; I am sure the local dentists would have been relieved to hear that. He seemed happy enough in his little world, but I sent a letter to the Social Services Department about him, which probably went straight into the round filing cabinet under the desk.

Sadly, in recent years there have been many reports of people doing the same thing as Mr. Jex because of a shortage of NHS dentists.

Hidden Assets

One day I visited an elderly gentleman and asked the usual questions about capital assets as these could affect the rate of benefit paid. He had been visited by 'sponge-man' six months before but had obviously not been asked the right questions. To my horror the pensioner produced a huge pile of National Savings Certificates that were unrecorded. It took me the best part of an hour to take the details, and many more hours back at the office valuing them. This reduced his benefit entitlement by several pounds per week and he had been overpaid. Given that it should have been picked up earlier, I wrote the overpayment off.

At De'Ath's Door

One day I was given a review visit for a lady whose surname was spelt De'Ath - one I had not come across before. As I walked up to the door, I was wondering how to greet her. Was it Mrs. Deeth, or Mrs. De Ath? I settled on the latter.

"Good morning, I have come to see Mrs. De Ath". "It's not De Ath - it's DEATH" she replied in a voice that Terry Pratchett would have recognised. I think it was her party piece. She was a nice lady.

Catwoman

Rutland had more than its share of eccentrics. I made an emergency visit to an old lady who had written to the office saying that she didn't have any money to buy food. Her house was surrounded by an unkempt hedge that would not have looked out of place in the Grimm Brothers story of 'The Sleeping Beauty'.

There were cats on top of the hedge, at the foot of the hedge and on the path leading to the house. She had at least twenty of the mangy-looking creatures and had spent her entire pension on cat food. She told me that she took in strays as she 'couldn't see them starve'. The cottage stank of cat pee and there was cat faeces all over the house that she had not cleared up. I made an emergency payment to tide her over and made another referral to the Social Services Department. I am sure they must have hated me.

Travelling Showmen

I made a routine visit to review the payments to a retired couple who lived in an antique showman's caravan on a plot alongside a park in the middle of Melton Mowbray. The caravan was a magnificent contraption with very large steel-rimmed wheels, and when in use would have been pulled by horses. It was made mostly of mahogany and had not moved since the couple retired many years earlier. The inside was also beautiful with wooden carvings and etched glass mirrors. It would be worth a fortune today and is hopefully in a museum where it deserves to be. They had clearly made a good living in their time and were nothing like some of the 'new age travellers' I visited from time to time. These folks were very keen to dissociate themselves from such people who they said would "not know what a day's work is".

I can't find an image online that does justice to this caravan, but you can get some idea of the interior from the image below - though this is vulgar by comparison.

ShowmansCaravanInterior
Interior of a Showman's caravan [6]

Another retired travelling showman I visited lived in a much more modest caravan. He complained that he found it difficult to walk because of a problem with his foot and insisted on showing me what he called 'a big twister', which was some kind of enormous wart on the sole of his foot and about two inches across. I told him to see a doctor or hospital about it but I doubt whether he ever went. It may well have been too advanced to deal with apart from by major surgery. I am not keen on feet at the best of times!

The Leicestershire 'Hannah Hauxwell'

Hannah Hauxwell (1926-2018) was a farmer who lived a solitary life at Low Birk Hall Farm in the North Riding of Yorkshire who became famous in the 1970s from TV programmes made about her hard life. She lived to be 91.

HannahHauxwell
Hannah Hauxwell at her farm [136]

One day I visited Hannah's uncelebrated Leicestershire equal. Many of the people I visited lived in remote spots, but this was an exceptional case. The old lady lived in a ramshackle house on top of a hill along a farm track with no proper made-up path. The house had no mains electricity, gas, water or drainage. She drew water from a well, gathered wood from hedgerows and cooked on an open fire. The furniture was very old and sparse, and the table was covered in newspaper in place of a tablecloth. She wore extremely old clothes but was clean and appeared to be in good health. I asked whether there was anything she needed but she politely declined help and was happy just getting her pension each week.

Death Without an Apostrophe

A few weeks later I went to call on another old lady in the village of Bottesford. 'Sponge-man' was supposed to have called several times before me but, failing to contact her, did what he usually did - nothing. She lived in an alms house owned by a small local charity.

Failing to get a reply I called on the neighbours, who said they had not seen her for a while, then went to the office of the charity who were not really interested. I was not at all happy with this situation and went to the local police station and insisted on a constable coming to the house with me. We couldn't see anything through the windows and the constable decided to force the door.

There was a terrible smell inside and we found the old lady dead in bed. It was the middle of a hot summer, and she had left a fan heater on full blast. The place was full of flies, and her body was black with decay.

I felt sick and went straight home. There was an inquest, but the matter was hushed up as the people running the charity were local bigwigs.

The Alcoholic Granny

'Sponge-man' was kept on visiting duties far too long and was one of the laziest people I have come across in all my years at work. He had claimed to have made several attempts to see an old lady on the Beaumont Leys Estate but, once again, had made no attempt to follow this up to ensure that she was OK. This was not long after I had found the old lady dead in her bed at Bottesford.

This 80-year-old had been moved to a new council house. I called on the next-door neighbour and asked if she had seen the old lady. It was about 12 o'clock. The neighbour laughed and told me that there was no point in trying to visit her when the pubs were open and to call early in the morning to stand any chance of catching her in.

Two Aged Brothers

Bottesford, in the northernmost part of Leicestershire, was one of the larger villages in the rural part of our area and I seemed to go there most weeks. I called to see a pensioner who was aged 94 according to the records. I knocked on the door, and an old chap came out which I assumed was him. "No" he said, "you want my young brother - he has just cycled down to the shops to get some milk. Hang on he will be back in 5 minutes" - which he was. The brother that opened the door was 98.

The Hoarder

Yet another visit to Bottesford, this time to a lady pensioner. I don't think hoarding was as common in those days as it is now, and I had not encountered a hoarder before; this lady would now be described as an obsessive-compulsive hoarder. She kept absolutely everything, but her hoard was carefully cleaned and segregated. The whole house was full of piles of neatly stacked cornflake packets, washed baked bean cans - you name it. She seemed sensible enough, but the staircase had piles of newspapers along each side from top to bottom with a pathway through the middle and the place was obviously a fire hazard. Once again, I notified the Social Services Department. I have no idea whether they did anything as I didn't return.

The Sculpture

I entered a large and nicely built privately rented stone cottage whilst visiting a lady pensioner living in a village in Rutland. I couldn't help noticing an enormous stone sculpture in the entrance hall and asked her about it. It was by someone that I had heard of who she had known when young who had given it to her. I considered whether it should be treated as a capital asset for benefit purposes as it was clearly very valuable but decided to turn a blind eye to it anyway. Good luck to her to have something beautiful in her house - not many people did.

The Squire

Rutland again - this time an urgent visit to a 30-year-old single woman giving her address as a house in a very remote hamlet. I knocked on the door but, failing to get a response, wandered around the side to see if she was in the garden. I was accosted by a man who looked like a caricature of a 'Squire of the Manor' - he was just missing a monocle. He told me to clear off because he had not been asked permission for the woman to have anyone visiting her. It struck me as very odd that dinosaurs still existed in Rutland but there was nothing I could do. Another countryside mystery.

The Vicar-Basher

One day I called on a vicar somewhere in Rutland in a matter related to one of his parishioners. He was out and I spoke to someone at the vicarage but couldn't tell her the purpose of my visit as it was confidential. There had been a recent incident somewhere in the country - nowhere near Rutland! - where a stranger had broken into the house of a vicar and assaulted him. The lady I spoke to was suspicious and wrote down my car registration number. On his return, the vicar phoned the police. Having recently been suspected of murder, vicar-bashing was trivial!

I was in the yellow Ford Capri that I had just purchased from Rob, but it was still registered in his name as the transfer of registration had not been processed by the licencing authority DVLA. While I was still out visiting, Rob got a knock on the door from the 'Old Bill' who asked whether he was the owner of car FOL 855L. Rob said he had sold it but, suspecting that I might have done something naughty, and not wanting to drop me in it, told the police he didn't have my details. Rob told me about this in the evening but in the meantime the 'vicar-basher' had been apprehended, and I heard nothing more about it.

Rising Damp

The New Parks Estate in Leicester had a very bad reputation, although it improved a great deal when the council renovated most of the houses. Before the improvements, I visited a single woman with a clutch of kids. She invited me into the front room and to sit on the sofa. After a few minutes my backside felt damp and, together with the smell, I realised that her children had been relieving themselves on it. This also explained why three of them were wandering around the house with no clothes on. I took her statement in record time and quickly drove home to have a shower and change my clothes. After this visit I developed a technique of taking statements standing up whilst in similar houses and gave the excuse that I couldn't sit down as I had a bad back.

Hot Dog Anyone?

Harrison Road is to the north of Leicester City Centre and consists of the standard Victorian working-class terraced houses that make up the older parts of the city. I lived in a house of the same kind in the Newfoundpool area to the west of the city and they have lasted well despite their cheap construction.

I was given the file for a newly unemployed man who had moved there. My colleagues sniggered when they saw the address but wouldn't explain why. From the outside it was just another terraced house, though perhaps a bit grubbier than its neighbours. It turned out that the place was run like a Victorian dosshouse by an old woman who would take in anyone who was prepared to pay, and who presumably had no sense of smell.

I was invited into the rear room which had a couple of battered armchairs and an old wooden table and chairs. It stank in a way that only people who have visited this kind of place can imagine. The table was covered with dirty newspapers rather than a tablecloth. On it stood a paraffin primus stove on which was a heavy frying pan that was full of grease and had something burnt and unrecognisable floating in it that might once have been sausages but would have required analysis by a pathologist to be sure.

To complete this picture of homeliness and domestic bliss, the landlady's dog was standing on the table and as I came in it emptied its bowels next to the frying pan before jumping down to the floor. I used my new skill of taking statements whilst standing up and got out as quickly as possible.

When I described my visit back at the office my colleagues showed their sympathy by howling with laughter. I reported the place to the authorities as a health hazard, but it was still in business when I left the office.

The Circus

One of the most unusual claims I handled was from the owner of a small circus that was spending the Winter in a field somewhere in Rutland. There was a miniature 'Big Top' and the various performers were practicing their acts, juggling, walking tightropes, swinging on trapezes etc. The owner was trying to claim benefit because the circus made no money over the Winter period, and they were struggling to get by.

The UK benefits system has always struggled to deal with people with irregular incomes and still does. All I could do initially was collect the basic facts and submit the matter to our Regional Office for advice on how to proceed. They had no idea either and passed it to the department's headquarters in London. A couple of weeks later I was asked to go back and ask for copies of the circus accounts for the previous year, which I had to summarise and send on. It was at least a couple of months before a reply was received, which was basically that no benefit should be paid and that the whole cast should register for work as individuals.

Circus people tend to get bad press, but I have to say that having met quite a few of them over the years, I have found them hardworking, honest and respectable.

Ugandan Asians

The British administration that ruled Uganda between 1894 and 1962 brought large numbers of Asians into the country to work there - mainly Indians and Pakistanis. Most of them worked in commerce and administrative roles and it is argued that they were given better treatment by the government than indigenous Ugandans - particularly in education. This led to anti-Indian feeling that was exploited by Idi Amin who had declared himself President of Uganda in 1971 in a coup d'état. Amin expelled as many of them as he could in 1972 and an estimated 50,000 came to the UK, of which around 20,000 settled in Leicester.

IdiAmin
Idi Amin in 1978 [133]

Many of the older immigrants had little or no English and struggled to adapt. They were of course entitled to claim benefits, but this created additional problems from an administrative point of view as claim forms had to be completed in English. Many had younger family members who spoke English and could translate for them, but quite a few didn't. One way or another I had to find someone to translate which took extra time and the completed forms had then to be read back and re-translated to the claimant so they could confirm what I had written was correct. I had my doubts about some of the translations but there was nothing else we could do. A note would be made on the claim that it had been translated, and who the translator was, in case of a query. I am not aware of any cases of fraud, but I suspect it would have been impossible to prosecute in a case like this.


Many of the people who had come from Uganda lived in terraced houses in streets off the Melton Road at the north end of Leicester. I can remember calling to visit one old lady to find a wedding reception in full swing in the house. I was immediately pulled inside and invited to have something to eat but, much as I like Asian food, I had just had my lunch. Not wishing to appear rude, I asked if I could just have something sweet. I was given a large plate of sweetmeats that were the sweetest things I have tasted in my life. It is no surprise to me that the rate of diabetes in India is very high, though surpassed by Pakistan, China, USA, Mexico and Egypt.


Some of the Leicester people I met in pubs from time to time would sound off about 'dirty' immigrants. This annoyed me greatly as the only dirty houses I had visited were occupied by white British people and I said so in no uncertain terms. This never went down well.

The Pianola

One day I called on an elderly lady on the Northfields estate who was complaining that she needed to get rid of she didn't use and indicated a shabby-looking pianola that stood in her main living room. She said she thought it still worked but nobody had touched it for years and she wanted the space for a bed for her dog.

I had been fascinating by mechanical instruments since seeing them demonstrated in the Leicester Newarke Houses Museum and asked if I could have a look at it. The casing was very grubby, the keys were the colour of an octogenarian hyena's teeth, and it was horribly out of tune. Although probably acting unethically, I asked her whether she wanted to sell it. She said she just wanted to get rid of it so I made her an offer that she was very happy with, gave her the money and arranged for a piano-moving company to collect it.

Ordinary pianos are heavy enough to move but pianolas are twice as heavy due to the weight of the mechanism and the yards of miniature lead pipework in the works. The head removal man was tiny but moved the massive thing on a trolley with minimal help from his assistant and deposited it in my front room.

To my surprise, when I fitted a piano roll and started pumping the pedals it wheezed into life straight away though clearly needed a lot of TLC. I removed perhaps forty years of dust with a vacuum cleaner, cleaned and polished the woodwork, treated the keys with a chemical to remove the yellowing and had it professionally tuned. I then set about looking at the works and improving the performance with guidance from a book by Arthur Ord-Hume that I still have.

OrdHumePianola
Frront cover of Ord-Hume's book on the pianola [60]

A few years after finishing work on the pianola we moved house, but the removal company couldn't get it through the front door of our new house, so it had to be sold. I kept the box of piano rolls that came with it and still have these in my attic. I would like to get another pianola one day, though I am not sure I have enough room for one. There is much more about pianolas and piano rolls HERE.

It was only in doing research for these pages that I discovered that my old office at City Road in London was once a factory making pianola rolls and that some of them might have been made there.

Problem Cases

Benefits Officers were not well thought of in some quarters but had a lot to put up with at times. I have made light of some of the threats made to me, but a lady visiting officer in Telford was murdered by a claimant while I was working in Leicester. Here are some examples of my more unpleasant experiences.

Indecent Exposure

I called on an elderly disabled man who lived in a village in Rutland to bring his records up to date. I knocked on the door; it was unlocked and he called me to come in. He was very fat and sitting in a wheelchair with his penis in his hand playing with himself. There was something very odd in the way he spoke - sardonic and sad. I felt more pity than disgust. A female visiting officer might have felt very uncomfortable or threatened. I told him to 'put it away', completed the interview, went to a local pub to wash my hands and had the case marked with a 'red spot' to ensure that future visits would be accompanied.

Inspiration for 'The Slobs'?

Northfields was one of Leicester's oldest and most run-down council estates. I saw many grim sights over the years, but nothing prepared me for a visit to the family of James N. This large family lived in a solid but shabby-looking three-bedroomed house. On going inside, I found that the man, his wife and five children were all sleeping on mattresses covering the floor of one downstairs room. There was a washing up bowl full of urine in the middle of the floor and the smell was overpowering. They were sleeping in one room as most of the woodwork in the house, including the upstairs floorboards, had been chopped up as firewood.

I could see what appeared to be a bundle of rags in a cot in the alcove to the left of the chimney breast. After a few moments the pile of rags moved, and I realised that there was a baby in there. Another referral to the poor Social Services Department; goodness knows what could be done to sort this lot out. The family was well-known in the office and no member of it had done a day's work in generations.

I enjoyed Harry Enfield's TV programmes in the 1990s and much of it included shrewd observation of people. This family could easily have been the inspiration for his characters 'The Slobs'. They were not the only family I visited that lived in filth and squalor, but this was truly exceptional.

Over My Dead Body

I have already mentioned that Civil Service pay was poor and that many of the people I dealt with got more in benefits than I got in wages. This didn't normally bother me as I knew that my income would rise over time. But just occasionally, the antics of certain individuals did get to me.

The most annoying case was that of a woman from London who had been rehoused by the Local Authority in a house in Victoria Street, Melton Mowbray. At that time the street was being used as a dumping ground for problem families, though looking at it now on Google Street View, I am pleased to see that it has returned to respectability. She was the archetypal waster, with five children by different men, none of whom contributed to their upkeep ... but that is beside the point.

I called just after she had moved in. The family had nothing but the clothes they stood up in and the unfurnished house was completely empty. I had no choice but to provide everything they needed from furniture to clothes. I arranged for a set of essential furniture to be delivered by a local dealer with whom we had arrangements as there is no way we would have paid cash in these circumstances. Giro payments were made for her to purchase essential clothes for the children and by the time I had left the family were fully provided for. I also arranged for weekly benefit payments by a book of orders to be cashed at the local post office.

Over the next few weeks, the office got regular calls saying her money had been lost or stolen, and finally that someone had broken in and taken the entire set of furniture from the house. She called at the office demanding that we replace the furniture.

I had had enough of her at that point and called her into a private interview booth and told her that she would only get more furniture 'over my dead body', but for some reason it came out as two words, the second of which was 'off'. She went outside, found a policeman and dragged him into the office where she accused me of verbal abuse. I kept a straight face as I denied it and the policeman left.

She appealed against my refusal to the Independent Appeals Tribunal who, having heard the arguments from both sides, confirmed my decision, though they probably would not have approved of how I had communicated it to her. Her children were taken into care - probably the best thing that happened to the poor things.

The Melton Murderer

I have mentioned being regularly threatened by benefit claimants but that it was all hot air - well it usually was. If someone said they were going to smash my head in, I would respond that they would have to wait for me to come out of the office at 6PM. Nobody did as the pubs were open by then.

The only instance when I thought my life was really in danger was during a visit to a woman in Melton Mowbray. Maybe there was something in the air from the pie factories, but the town had more than its share of 'wrong 'uns'. Her file was marked with the warning 'red spot' indicating that all visits should be accompanied due to the risk of violence or sexual assault. She had been living with a well-known thug who had been sent to prison for murder but, unknown to the office, had been released on parole. The woman made a claim saying she was living on her own, so I was allocated the visit without being accompanied.

When I reached the house, the woman invited me in. I was surprised to find that her neanderthal partner was sitting in the front room in the alcove to the left of the fireplace. I could no longer take a claim from the woman as they were living as a couple under the same roof and the claim would have to be in his name.

As I sat down, Ug got out a large knife, started sharpening it and tried to intimidate me by staring directly at me. He was successful and I needed to get out - preferably without the knife stuck in me. I lied by telling them that I was a junior officer and that his presence complicated matters so I would have to consult the manager before proceeding but that I would return. I slowly got up and so did Ug with the knife held in front of him. I walked very slowly backwards to the front door and made an ignominious exit, nearly falling arse-over-head descending the steps outside the front door. I was content with ignominious - at least I was unstabbed.

There was no need to go back as, before another visit could be arranged, the man committed another offence and was locked up for several years.

The 'Reasonable Man'

One of the most tricky types of case to deal with were those where a man and woman lived at the same address but claimed that they were maintaining separate households so should each be able to claim benefit. Because of the benefit rules, if this was accepted, they would get more in benefits than they would if treated as a couple, which would clearly be unfair if they were not telling the truth.

We were faced with having to make a difficult decision and were not allowed to ask them whether they had a sexual relationship - and in any case this was not the only consideration, for there are many couples who do not have a sexual relationship. We had to decide the claim using a wide set of criteria which involved asking about whether they prepared their own meals, kept separate finances etc. The number of bedrooms in the house could be considered, but this was rarely helpful. This process was far from easy, but we had to do our best to follow the legal guidance and use our judgement. The only time my decision on this topic was challenged at an Appeals Tribunal was the case described here.

I was given a case of a man in his late 50s who had always lived on his own but had taken a woman and her four children into his house. After going through the process, rightly or wrongly, I concluded that no 'reasonable man' would have taken these people in and still maintained a separate household. I issued a decision that they had to be treated as a married couple and he would have to claim for the whole family. They appealed against my decision, but the Independent Appeals Tribunal agreed with me and rejected the appeal.

A few months later the man was convicted of having sexual intercourse with the woman's 14-year-old daughter. I wondered whether the mother had been complicit but will never know.

Colleagues

There were three Clerical Officers and six Executive Officers in the visiting team. One of the EOs organised future visits for everyone and authorised assessments made by the CO visitors, and one of the COs checked the assessments completed by the EO visitors. Apart from 'sponge-man' who I have already mentioned, the others were all very professional and a pleasure to work with.

Leicester was a multi-cultural city with a large Asian and smaller Polish, West Indian and other communities long before I moved there and, over time the DHSS employed more people from these communities. The visiting team included two people from India, and I was surprised to see significant friction between them. I am not sure whether this was based on caste or the part of India they came from, but it was rather unpleasant at times, and they often insulted one another in Hindi.

The next page continues the account of my time at Leicester DHSS.