Partition of India
The banner image is from a photograph by Margaret Bourke-White showing a tiny part of the hardship that resulted from the mass migration that followed immediately after partition [183].
Most people would have regarded taking on the job of 'Last Viceroy' as a 'poisoned chalice' but Mountbatten seems to have seen it as an opportunity to enhance his own status.
Negotiations over independence quickly reached an impasse; Jinnah refused to give ground on the Muslim desire for a separate state. Whether he would have come around given more effort is a matter for conjecture, but Mountbatten was not going to hang around. Eventually the Indian National Congress agreed to partition - with the proviso that Bengal and Punjab should be divided, despite them having a small majority of Muslims.
With reckless haste, on 3 June 1947, Mountbatten announced that the date of foundation of the independent states of Pakistan and would be 14 and 15 August 1947 - six months earlier than the deadline he had been given by Attlee. Mountbatten made a public broadcast the following day. A recording of his broadcast can be heard on YouTube [134]; it was widely reported in newspapers including 'The Times'.
The Boundary Commissions
Now that partition was inevitable, the boundaries between India and Pakistan had to be determined. Residents of Bengal, Punjab and part of the North-West Province voted on which state they wanted to belong to, but this did not provide a straightforward solution. The Princely States were not British possessions, and it would be for the princes and maharajahs to decide whether to remain independent or to join one of the new Dominions that were being created; Mountbatten had no power to enforce this.
The British rapidly set up two boundary commissions and wheeled in British lawyer Sir Cyril Radcliffe who was supposed to be impartial. Radcliffe chaired both commissions and Mountbatten gave him the unrealistic deadline of completing this task within five weeks. The commissions had representatives from the Indian National Congress and the Muslim League.
Unsurprisingly, the two political groups were unable to agree, and it was left to Radcliffe to make the difficult decisions. There were no natural boundaries that could be used, many areas had borderline Muslim majority populations, nobody involved in the process had experience of drawing boundaries, they had no experts they could call on, and they had been given an impossible deadline.
It is hardly surprising that the resulting report led to problems - though in fairness to Radcliffe, I suspect that there would have been disagreement wherever he had drawn the boundaries. In some cases, the boundary went through the middle of villages and, to add to the volatile mixture, Sikhs wanted their own state, and Buddhists in parts of Bengal had not been consulted at all.
Radcliffe completed his map by the deadline, delivered it to Mountbatten and left India almost before the ink was dry on his report. He destroyed his working notes and refused the fee he was to be paid. Given the aftermath, this is hardly surprising - it would have been 'blood money'. Radcliffe had not been to India before his engagement and, wisely, never returned.
In 1966, W.H.Auden wrote a poem about Radcliffe which I think sums his involvement up quite well:
Partition
Unbiased at least he was when he arrived on his mission,
Having never set eyes on the land he was called to partition
Between two peoples fanatically at odds,
With their different diets and incompatible gods.
“Time,” they had briefed him in London, “is short. It’s too late
For mutual reconciliation or rational debate:
The only solution now lies in separation.
The Viceroy thinks, as you will see from his letter,
That the less you are seen in his company the better,
So we’ve arranged to provide you with other accommodation.
We can give you four judges, two Moslem and two Hindu,
To consult with, but the final decision must rest with you.”
Shut up in a lonely mansion, with police night and day
Patrolling the gardens to keep the assassins away,
He got down to work, to the task of settling the fate
Of millions. The maps at his disposal were out of date
And the Census Returns almost certainly incorrect,
But there was no time to check them, no time to inspect
Contested areas. The weather was frightfully hot,
And a bout of dysentery kept him constantly on the trot,
But in seven weeks it was done, the frontiers decided,
A continent for better or worse divided.
The next day he sailed for England, where he could quickly forget
The case, as a good lawyer must. Return he would not,
Afraid, as he told his Club, that he might get shot.
Partition
In addition to boundary issues, the armed forces and all manner of infrastructure had to be divided between the two new states. Mountbatten deliberately withheld passing the boundary plan to the India and Pakistan representatives until 16 August - the day after the independence ceremonies.
Abul Kalam Azad, a Muslim member of the Indian National Congress, expressed his concerns to Mountbatten about the likelihood of violent riots. Mountbatten gave this dismissive response - which indicates that either he was out of touch with reality or that he was not concerned about what would happen:
At least on this question I shall give you complete assurance. I shall see to it that there is no bloodshed and riot. I am a soldier and not a civilian. Once the partition is accepted in principle, I shall issue orders to see that there are no communal disturbances anywhere in the country. If there should be the slightest agitation, I shall adopt the sternest measures to nip the trouble in the bud.
Mountbatten was true to his word on the date of independence - if nothing else. Pakistan came into being on 14 August 1947 and India on 15 August 1947. Just about everyone realised that partition would lead to bloodshed and the British wanted to pass the blame on to others. Mountbatten wanted to get the independence ceremony over before the boundary shit hit the fan; disputes after that could be blamed on the members of the respective Dominions.
The map below shows how the sub-continent was divided. It also shows the resulting migration of people which will be described in more detail below. At the date of the Independence ceremonies, people living in many areas did not know which state they would be living in.
The Reality of Partition
The withdrawal of British forces started almost immediately and was completed by February 1948, with responsibility for maintaining peace and security dumped onto the disorganised new Dominions.
I cannot do justice to the harrowing story of what happened after Independence here and will restrict myself to a short bullet-point summary. There are many accounts from all sides and a vast number of books, television programmes and films made about the ensuing chaos. A variety of Ethnic Cleansing based on religion was unleashed.
- Neither the British Government, the Indian National Congress nor the All-India Muslim League expected the massive movement of people across the borders that occurred - they all seemed to have thought that religious minorities would remain where they were. The reality was that, fearing for their lives and harassed by zealots from all religious groups - Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs, they fled in their millions
- Estimates of the number of displaced people vary between ten and twenty million people - probably the largest refugee crisis ever known
- Estimates of the numbers of deaths in the period following partition range from 200,000 (Mountbatten's estimate) to 2 million
- An analysis of 'before and after' data suggests that up to 3.4 million people could not be accounted for - though it is likely that some of these had moved to countries other than India and Pakistan [142]
Could partition have been done better? There are so many questions that cannot be answered including these:
- Would there have been less displacement of people and loss of life if it had been carried out more slowly as some have argued?
- Would taking longer to sort out the boundaries simply have caused different problems?
- Was Mountbatten right to push forward and get it over and done with?
- Was it a good idea to use Radcliffe for this task and could someone else have done a better job at drawing the line?
- Would things have turned out better if Nehru had taken a different attitude?
Who was responsible for the bloodshed? While the British must bear a lot of the responsibility, local political leaders and religious hotheads on all sides must share the blame. Writer A.N. Wilson had no doubts as to Mountbatten's part in the death toll [140]:
Much of the blame for the way that partition was handled - its brusque haste, its insufficient policing, the genocidal carelessness with which the fine print and the borders were decided - must be laid at the door of Louis Mountbatten, whose government awarded him an Earldom in October 1947. By his superficial haste, his sheer arrogance, his inattention to vital detail, and his unwillingness to provide the huge peace-keeping forces which could have protected migrant populations, Mountbatten was responsible for as many deaths as some of those who were hanged after the Nuremberg trials.
Dominions
Mountbatten became Governor-General of the Dominion of India with Nehru as Prime Minister. Jinna baulked at the idea of Mountbatten becoming Governor-General of Pakistan and insisted on taking that role himself. To the great annoyance of Mountbatten, Jinna appointed Liaquat Ali Khan as Prime Minister. Jinna believed that Mountbatten would side with Nehru in the case of disputes - and may well have been correct.
The Princely States
Within the sub-continent there had been no less than 362 'Princely States'. The largest was Hyderabad with an area very slightly less than that of Scotland at 77,000 square miles, though over 200 of them were of less than 10 square miles. By August 1947, all but three had fallen into line with most joining India. Hyderabad and the tiny Junagadh were incorporated into India by military force; Amb, Bahawalpur, Chitral, Dir, Kalat, Khairpur, Kharan, Las Bela, Makran, and Swat joined Pakistan. Kashmir remained in dispute, and indeed still is.
Full Independence
India would remain a Dominion until 26 January 1950 when it became the Republic of India. Mountbatten remained Governor General until 21 June 1948 when he was succeeded by Chakravarti Rajagopalachari who became the last Governor-General.
Pakistan remained a Dominion until 23 March 1956 when it became the Islamic Republic of Pakistan. Iskander Mirza was the last Governor-General from 7 August 1955 to 23 March 1956.
It seems strange that both India and Pakistan shared the British monarch until they became independent republics in 1950 and 1956 respectively.
