World War II

Banner

The Royal Appeasers

It is understandable that, after the horrors of 'The Great War', or 'The War to End All Wars', nobody wanted a repeat performance. This led many people, including the royal family, to be in favour of appeasing the various fascists.

King George V had been too old and ill to do anything more than express his concern about the rise of the Nazis to the British Ambassador to Germany, but he was most definitely an appeaser. His response to British ships being sent to the Mediterranean in 1935 when Mussolini invaded Abyssinia in 1935 was to say to Foreign Secretary Samuel Hoare [152 page 6]:

I am an old man. I have been through one world war. How can I go through another? If I am to go on you must keep us out of this one.

To Lloyd George he said [126 page 387]:

I will not have another war. I will not. The last one was none of my doing and if there is another one and we are threatened with being brought into it, I will go to Trafalgar Square and wave a red flag myself sooner than allow this country to be brought in.

King Edward VIII

Edward was a Nazi sympathiser. According to the papers of journalist Robert Bruce Lockhart, this was clear from 1933 when he was Prince of Wales. Lockhart reported Edward's conversation with the Kaiser's grandson Prince Louis Ferdinand [163]:

The Prince of Wales was quite 'pro-Hitler' (and) said it was no business of ours to interfere in Germany's internal affairs either re Jews or re anything else and added that 'the Dictators were very popular these days and we might want one in England before long.'

George had given Edward the title 'Duke of Windsor' after his abdication and with it came the style 'His Royal Highness'. No title was ever given to Wallis Simpson, despite their marriage in France on 3 June 1937. To add insult to injury, the Church of England had declined to perform the ceremony.

The Reverend Robert Anderson Jardine (1878–1950), vicar of a working-class parish in Darlington, offered to officiate at the marriage, but he was to pay a heavy price for his action. The Bishop of Durham, Dr. Herbert Hensley Henson, forbade it, but the independent-minded Jardine went ahead anyway on the basis that the bishop had no jurisdiction over what happened in France - which was technically true. On his return to Darlington Jardine found himself out of a job. He later left for America but was not allowed to stay and spent most of the war years in Mexico. He was eventually offered a church post in South Africa but died before he could take it up.

To Edward's extreme annoyance, George forbade the attendance of the British royals. One of the consequences of the 'Duke of Windsor' title was that Edward would not be able to serve as a Member of Parliament, nor to speak on political matters in the House of Lords, so he was politically neutered. The government refused to include Edward in the Civil List but an allowance was paid to him by George. He sold Balmoral Castle and Sandringham House to George for many millions but despite this continually pestered George for money and badgered him to give Wallis a title until George finally refused to take telephone calls from him.

Edward's sympathy for the Nazi regime became even clearer after his abdication with a tour of Nazi Germany in October 1937 during which his greeting by Hitler and other Nazi leaders caused a great deal of embarrassment to the British government. During the tour, the couple visited factories - many involved in Germany's rearmament effort in the face of the Treaty of Versailles, and the Duke inspected German troops. Greeted by the British National Anthem and Nazi salutes, the couple dined with Joseph Goebbels, Hermann Göring, Joachim von Ribbentrop, and Albert Speer, as well as having tea with Adolf Hitler in Berchtesgaden.

At one point during the trip, the Duke had a long private conversation with Hitler, but the minutes of their meeting were, conveniently, lost in the war. The Duchess took afternoon tea with Hitler's deputy, Rudolf Hess. Hitler was sympathetic to the Windsors and treated the Duchess like royalty.

Roosevelt And Churchill
Wallis and Edward with Hitler 1937 [154]

On 8 May, as King George VI and Queen Elizabeth were on their way to America for a royal visit, the NBC network broadcast an interview with Edward that he had recorded at Verdun - the site of a major WW1 battlefield. The speech, which is reproduced below from an American newspaper, was regarded by most people as supporting appeasement. The BBC refused to broadcast it, but it was broadcast around the world.

Cutting
Text of Duke of Windsor's 8 May speech - cutting from 'The Philadelphia Inquirer' [59]

It is interesting to read the British newspapers from this period. Edward was still looked up to by the British public, and this was reflected in press coverage. There seems to have been no official refutation of the speech Edward made in America, but it was not allowed to be broadcast.


Edward and Wallis were close friends of the British fascist leader Sir Oswald Mosley and his wife Diana - the latter writing a biography of Wallis in 1980. Although it sits uncomfortably now, there was a lot of public sympathy for fascist views in Britain and America. It is even claimed that Churchill was an admirer of Mussolini at one point. Antisemitism was also widespread in Britain, though not as virulent as in Germany and Russia. In the 1960s I mentioned having Jewish friends at school to my grandfather and was appalled when he said to me, Never trust a Jew!. I have no idea where that came from - neither of my parents were antisemitic or expressed racist views.

Both the British Secret Service and the FBI kept tabs on Edward and Wallis. Some claim that he passed intelligence to the Nazis; the Nazis certainly planned to make use of him as a 'puppet' king should they have conquered Britain. The extent to which Edward was a true supporter of Hitler's regime has been a matter of debate ever since.

There are many books written about the Windsors. I will just say here that, after his abdication and becoming Duke of Windsor, he lived in France with Wallis, moved to Spain as Hitler's forces overwhelmed France and was given a meaningless job as the Governor of the Bahamas by Churchill to get him out of the way and to minimise future embarrassment.

There is much that could be said about Edward, but others have done so far better than I ever could. As far as India and Durbars are concerned, he went out of the picture as soon as he abdicated.

King George VI

Whilst not a Nazi sympathiser like his brother, George, his wife Elizabeth and the other senior royals, were firmly in the appeasement camp and didn't seem particularly bothered about the Nazi's treatment of Jews or the annexation of Austria. In 1939, George went so far as to have his private secretary write to Halifax, the Foreign Secretary, suggesting he take steps to prevent Jews from leaving Germany and Austria and going to Palestine, which was administered by Britain on behalf of the League of Nations between 1920 and 1948. Although the worst atrocities of the Nazis were still to come, George was fully aware of what had happened on Kristallnacht. The Royals were more concerned about their own survival and regarded the rise of Communism as the greater threat.

George had a good relationship with Neville Chamberlain (1869-1940), who had become Prime Minister in May 1937, and with many of the 'appeasers' in parliament as they were closer to his own point of view.

Andrew Roberts makes the interesting observation that the senior politicians who advocated appeasement - Stanley Baldwin, Ramsay MacDonald, Neville Chamberlain, Samuel Hoare, Sir John Simon, Lord Halifax and Sir Kingsley Wood, had never seen military action. On the other hand, the 'anti-appeasers' Duff Cooper, Anthony Eden, Harold Macmillan, Winston Churchill, Roger Keyes and Louis Spears all had. [152 page 5].

During my research I came across references to the Évian Conference of 6–15 July 1938 that was held at Évian-les-Bains, France, to address the problem of German and Austrian Jewish refugees wishing to flee persecution by Nazi Germany. I think it is fair to summarise the conclusions of this failed conference as: We feel sorry for the Jews but don't want them causing problems in our country and don't want them. Had each country at the conference accepted a relatively small number of immigrants, some of the slaughter that followed in Germany might have been avoided - though maybe not much. It seems that Zionist representatives were not helpful as they were only interested in getting Jews moving to Palestine. Hitler was of course delighted with the outcome, as it supported his view that Jews were Germany's biggest problem, and that nobody else wanted them either.

The events leading up to WW2 are well known. After his visit to Munich in September 1938, Chamberlain believed that Hitler would behave himself. Whether this was naivety or wishful thinking I am not sure; he presumably hadn't realised that Hitler was a psychopath. In the event, his 'Peace for our time' speech got a mixed reception with an estimated three times as many people protesting against the Munich Agreement in Trafalgar Square than there were in favour of it at Downing Street. The Labour spokesman Hugh Dalton publicly suggested that the piece of paper that Chamberlain was waving was "torn from the pages of Mein Kampf".

In March 1939, Germany annexed the Bohemia and Moravia-Silesia areas of Czechoslovakia, ignoring the Munich agreement. Interestingly, Hitler likened relationship of the Germans to the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia he created to that between the British Raj and the 'Princely States' in India. Britain did nothing, though Chamberlain was moved to making a speech saying that 'he could not trust Hitler not to invade other countries' and in April Britain and France offered a guarantee of independence to Poland.

Britain Declares War on Germany

Hitler invaded Poland on 1 September 1939. Two days later Britain and France declared war on Germany. I am not going to say much more about the war other than explain how India was involved.

Britain's Dependence on India

The British desperately needed the Indian Army in WW2. In 1939, Viceroy and Governor-General of India Victor Hope, 2nd Marquess of Linlithgow (1887–1952), declared India to be at war with Germany without consulting the Indian National Congress. Congress made it clear that they would not support the war unless India became independent and, in 1942, launched the Quit India movement. The All-India Muslim League was generally supportive of the INC position. The government arrested about 60,000 Congress leaders, including Gandhi and Nehru, and most of them stayed locked up until the end of the war.

The British Indian Army grew from about 200,000 in 1939 to over 3 million by 1945. Indian forces included tank, artillery and airborne forces. They served in the North and East African Campaigns, the Western Desert Campaign, the Burma Campaign and the invasion of Italy.

A small contingent of anti-British Indians, led by Subhas Chandra Bose, set up the Indian National Army and fought with the Japanese against the allies but they don't seem to have had much impact on the course of events. Between November 1945 and May 1946, approximately ten courts-martial of former INA members were held in public at the Red Fort in Delhi where part of the 1911 Durbar had taken place. Ultimately this got mixed up with negotiations about independence and came to nothing.


As early as 1942, America's President Roosevelt and Britain's Prime Minister Churchill were thinking about their joint goals for the world after WW2 ended. Their conclusions became known as the Atlantic Charter - although it was never formally signed. The principal points were:

  • No territorial gains were to be sought by the United States or the United Kingdom
  • Territorial adjustments must be in accord with the wishes of the peoples concerned.
  • All people had a right to self-determination
  • Trade barriers were to be lowered.
  • There was to be global economic co-operation and advancement of social welfare
  • The participants would work for a world free of want and fear
  • The participants would work for freedom of the seas
  • There was to be disarmament of aggressor nations and a common disarmament after the war
Roosevelt And Churchill
Photograph of Roosevelt and Churchill - date unknown [145]

Britain had a major issue with the interpretation of the third point. It was not just Germany and Japan that had empires but also Britain, The Soviet Union and The Netherlands. The Americans insisted that the charter was to acknowledge that the war was being fought to ensure self-determination. In a September 1941 speech, Churchill stated that the charter was meant to apply only to states under German occupation, certainly not to those that were part of the British Empire.

In 1942 Gandhi wrote to Roosevelt stating his views on the matter - which seem fair to me:

I venture to think that the Allied declaration that the Allies are fighting to make the world safe for the freedom of the individual and for democracy sounds hollow so long as India and for that matter Africa are exploited by Great Britain.

Inevitably, each interpreted the 'Atlantic Charter' to support their own agenda. Despite these issues, it is worth recognising that the key principles of the 'Atlantic Charter' became the basis for the United Nations organisation. Roosevelt did not press the matter of Empires during the war and died before fighting had ended.

The End of the War

India paid a very high price for the war. It is estimated that 87,000 Indian servicemen were killed, a further 34,354 were wounded, and 67,340 had been taken as prisoners of war. During the war, Indian servicemen had been awarded over 6,000 medals for gallantry, including 31 Victoria Crosses. It is further estimated that somewhere between two and four million people died in Bengal in 1943 due to famine - or at least to them being unable to afford food. There are countless images of the famine available online, but I find them too disturbing to reproduce here.

Some commentators claim that a major cause of the death toll was the British War Cabinet refusing to allocate ships to transport grain to India from Australia. Fingers were pointed at Churchill, who was accused of racial prejudice towards Indians. Others point to the enormous loss of shipping in the Indian Ocean due to Axis attacks. I have not had time to research this, but it certainly seems that there were several factors at play - although the government could probably have done more.

A New Era

The next page is an account of the events immmediately following the end of WW2 that heralded the end of the British Empire and the coming of Indian independence.