Losses in WW1

War Clover War Firth War Monarch
War Patrol War Song War Swallow
Warilda Warnow Warren
Warrior


This page includes basic information about the ships and how they were lost, a photo of the relevant panel(s) of the Tower Hill Memorial and information about those that lost their lives extracted from the CWGC database. In the table I have included information about those who served on the ships but who had a normal burial as this seems appropriate to me. In some cases further family information about the individuals may be available on the CWGC website [7].

War Clover

War Clover was a 5,174 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1917 by Harland & Wolff, Ltd. for The British Government Shipping Controller and managed by T. Dixon & Sons Ltd. She was sunk on 19 October 1917 by torpedo fired by German submarine U-64 at position 37° 00' N, 12° 35' E - approximately 25 nautical miles East by North of Pantelleria. She was en route from Barry to Taranto with a cargo of coal.

War Clover

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Beck Alfred Reginald 24 19/10/1917 Third Mate Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Hannah Beck (Nee Matthews), Of 22, Pomeroy St., Cardiff, And The Late Edward Beck. Born At Cardiff.
Duffy Henry 18 19/10/1917 3rd Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Francis And Elizabeth Duffy, Of 14, Arlington St., Belfast.
Ennis Thomas 43 19/10/1917 Donkeyman and Greaser Tower Hill Memorial Son Of William John Ennis And The Late Agnes Ennis; Husband Of Annie Ennis (Nee Cuthbert), Of 52, Willowfield St., Belfast. Born At Belfast.
Griffin William 23 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of William Griffin, Of 75, New Dock St., Belfast, And The Late Jane Griffin.
Hopkins William Dalton 17 19/10/1917 Apprentice Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Alexander And Frances Jane Hopkins, Of 47, Thorndale Avenue, Larne, Co. Antrim.
Jennings George 37 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Margaret Jennings, And The Late Samuel Jennings; Husband Of Charlotte Jennings (Nee Carrothers), Of 38, Peveril St., Belfast. Born At Omagh.
Johnston Alexander 16 19/10/1917 Sailor Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Elizabeth Johnston (Nee Holmes), Of Ballykeel, Islandmagee, Co. Antrim, And The Late George Johnston.
McCafferty Patrick 18 19/10/1917 2nd Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of James McCafferty, Of 39, Marine St., Belfast, And The Late Mary Mccafferty.
McFall Alexander 32 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Esther McFall (Nee McKinley), Of 43, Harland St., Belfast. Born At Cork.
McGreevy John 36 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late John And Margaret McGreevy; Husband Of Annie McGreevy (Nee Rice), Of 20, Moffat St., Belfast. Born At Belfast.
McLarnon Patrick 34 19/10/1917 Boatswain Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late James And Bella McLarnon; Husband Of Catherine McLarnon (Nee Mateer), Of 4, Adelaide Avenue, Whitehead, Antrim. Born At Islandmagee.
Monaghan Bernard 49 19/10/1917 Greaser Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late Bernard And Martha Monaghan; Husband Of Margaret Monaghan (Nee Mcgregor), Of 23, Lancaster St., York St., Belfast. Born At Belfast.
Reilly Michael 40 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late William And Rose Reilly; Husband Of Rose Ann Reilly (Nee Creaney), Of 36, Gordon St., Belfast. Born In Co. Meath.
Wilde John 24 19/10/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial (Served As Mcnally). Son Of John And Jane Wilde, Of 2, Mellor St., Hooley Hill, Lancs.

War Firth

War Firth was a 3,112 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1918 by J. L. Thompson & Sons Ltd. for The British Shipping Controller and managed by J. Chadwick & Sons. She was sunk on 4 September 1918 by torpedo fired by German submarine U-53 approximately 33 nautical miles South by West of The Lizard. She was en route from Bilbao to the Clyde with a general cargo.

War Firth

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Adams Arthur Henry 31 04/09/1918 Chief Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Worthy And Eliza Adams; Husband Of Emily Adams (Nee Rowlands), Of Carlton House, Malpas Rd., Newport, Mon. Born At Newbridge, Mon.
Angus James 49 04/09/1918 Carpenter Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late William And Elizabeth Angus; Husband Of Isabella Angus (Nee Morgan), Of 8, New Quay, North Shields. Born At Kemnay, Aberdeenshire.
Carling James 52 04/09/1918 Donkeyman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late Jane Ann Carling; Husband Of The Late Margaret Carling (Nee Tait). Born At Sunderland.
Davison C 60 04/09/1918 Boatswain Tower Hill Memorial Born At Sunderland.
Fletcher William James 43 04/09/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Born At Liverpool. Son Of The Late Joseph And Ellen Fletcher; Husband Of Mary Fletcher (Nee Boswell), Of 20, Avison St., Liverpool.
Hanson Charlie 20 04/09/1918 Able Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Son of Vincent and Emma Hanson, of II, Sharp St., Wibsey, Bradford, Yorks. Mr. Hanson was a member of the Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve and is also commemorated on panel 31 of the Chatham Naval Memorial.
Jones James Gladstone 20 04/09/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Elizabeth Jones (Nee James), Of 11, Lewis St., Newport, Mon., And The Late Thomas Jones.
Laybourn James 51 04/09/1918 Greaser Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late John And Mary Ellen Laybourn; Husband Of The Late Annie Laybourn (Nee Pilton). Born At Sunderland.
Poole W 54 04/09/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial (Initial May Have Been N ). Born At Cardiff.
Turnbull William 24 04/09/1918 Third Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of John Smith Turnbull And Isabella Turnbull (Nee Gentles), Of 9, Villette Mount, Sunderland.
Vile Henry 29 04/09/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of William Henry Vile, Of 1, Silver St., Wells, Somerset, And The Late Maria Vile (Nee Wilkins).

War Monarch

War Monarch was a 7,887 GRT steam turbine powered cargo ship completed in 1917 by Union Iron Works Co. of Alameda, Calififornia for the British Government Shipping Controller and managed by Cunard Steamship Co. Ltd. She was sunk on 14 February 1918 by torpedo fired by German submarine UB-57 at position 50° 46' N, 00° 43' E - approximately 11 nautical miles East of the Royal Sovereign Light Vessel. She was en route from Hull to Italy with a cargo of coal.

War Monarch

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Davies Kenneth 22 14/02/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Selina Lockwood (Formerly Davies, Nee Hoff), Of 105, Regent St., Hull.
Mitchell E.C. 32 14/02/1918 Second Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Born In Isle Of Sheppy.
Shaw Frederick Charles 44 14/02/1918 Greaser Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late Frederick And Louise Shaw; Husband Of Florence Shaw (Nee Daniels), Of East Stockwith, Gainsborough, Lincoln. Born At Sheffield.

War Patrol

War Patrol was a 1,884 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1917 by Detroit Shipbuilding Co. of Wyandotte, Michigan for the British Government Shipping Controller and managed by J. Chambers & Co. She sank on 10 August 1917 after striking a mine laid by German submarine UC-69 at position 47° 48' N, 04° 25' W - approximately 1 nautical miles West of Penmarc'h. She was en route from Barry to an unknown destination with a cargo of coal.

War Patrol

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Adam John 35 10/08/1917 Able Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Thomas And The Late Elizabeth Adam; Husband Of Annie Ritchie Robertson Adam, Of Whites Buildings, William St., Tayport, Fife. Born At Dundee.
Connell James William 48 10/08/1917 First Mate Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Anne Eliza And The Late James Connell; Husband Of Amy Connell (Nee Humphreys), Of 12, Parliament Place, Liverpool. Born At Liverpool.
Cuthill James 41 10/08/1917 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of James Cuthill, Of 21, South Ellen St., Dundee, And The Late Jessie Cuthill.
Evans James 51 10/08/1917 Chief Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late James And Sarah Ann Evans; Husband Of Ann Evans (Nee Brownell), Of 124, Molyneaux Rd., Liverpool. Born At Liverpool.
Hawcko Leo 19 10/08/1917 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Thresa Hawcko, Of Roaches Line, British Cross Roads, Newfoundland.
McGee Francis 33 10/08/1917 Assistant Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late John And Ann Mcgee; Husband Of Jessie Mcgee (Nee Sangster), Of 36, Hilltown. Dundee. Born At Dundee.
Morgan Thomas Evan 23 10/08/1917 Third Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Mrs. Mary A. Morgan, Of 60, Mary St., Gilfynydd, Pontypridd. Born At Pontypridd.
Murdock Garnet 26 10/08/1917 Second Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Hannah Murdock (Nee Hughes) Of 62, Great Mersey St., Liverpool, And The Late Peter Murdock. Born At Liverpool.
Murphy George 19 10/08/1917 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Margaret Murphy, Of 10, Lindsay Square, Methil, Fife, And The Late Robert John Murphy.
Sheriffs James Henry 10/08/1917 Master Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Robert Chisholm Sheriffs And Margaret Sheriffs; Husband Of Isabella Sheriffs, Of 2, The Mount, Wallasey, Cheshire.
Snowden Henry 38 10/08/1917 Sailor Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late John And Rebecca Snowden; Husband Of Williamina Gavin Snowden (Nee Riddel), Of 22, Gellately St., Dundee, Forfar. Born At Hull.
Wilkie James 39 10/08/1917 Donkeyman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late James And Elizabeth Wilkie; Husband Of Margaret Jolly Lowman Wilkie, Of 24, Temple Lane, Dundee. Born At Dundee.
Wilson Thomas Hamilton 10/08/1917 Lance Corporal Tower Hill Memorial Mr. Wilson was a member of the Royal Marine Light Infantry and is also commemorated on panel 23 of the Plymouth Naval Memorial

War Song

War Song was a 2,535 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1917 by Detroit Shipbuilding Co. of Wyandotte, Michigan for the British Government Shipping Controller and managed by Wm. France, Fenwick & Co. Ltd. She was sunk on 15 January 1918 by gunfire from German submarine U-93 at position 48° 02' N, 05° 10' W - approximately 12 nautical miles Wes tof the Ile de Sein near Brest. She was en route from Bilbao to Brest with a cargo of iron ore.

War Song
War Song

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Abdullah Saleh 15/01/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Abdus Hamid 15/01/1918 Bhandary Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Ali Jumma 15/01/1918 Fireman Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Audigier Charles Lombard 16 15/01/1918 Boy L Isle-De-Sein New Communal Cemetery Coll. grave. Son Of Jules And Alexandra Audigier, Of 153, Uxbridge Rd., Shepherds Bush, London.
Brown M.T. 15/01/1918 Ship s Steward L Isle-De-Sein New Communal Cemetery Coll. grave.
Fleming Alfred Stalker 41 15/01/1918 First Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late John And Ann Fleming; Husband Of Mary Hannah Fleming (Nee Cogdon), Of 61, Bede St., Roker, Sunderland. Born At Sunderland.
Goulding William Patrick 52 15/01/1918 Second Officer L Isle-De-Sein New Communal Cemetery Coll. grave. Son Of Richard And Mary Goulding Of St. Kevins Rd., South Circular Rd., Dublin Ireland; Husband Of Mary Goulding, Of The Butts Gardens, Kilkenny, Ireland.
Hollingsworth J 29 15/01/1918 Second Engineer L Isle-De-Sein New Communal Cemetery Coll. grave. Son Of Mary Hollingsworth, Of 9, Lonsdale Rd., Roker, Sunderland, And The Late James Hollingsworth.
Muhammad Bin Ali 15/01/1918 Sailor Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Muhammad Zamin 15/01/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Ramsay James Rankine 48 15/01/1918 Mate L Isle-De-Sein New Communal Cemetery Coll. grave. Son Of James And Helen Ramsay; Husband Of Janet Ramsay, Of 36, Victoria Rd., Dundee.
Rasmussen A 25 15/01/1918 Carpenter Tower Hill Memorial Born In Denmark.
Said Umar 15/01/1918 Donkeyman Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
South J.G. 47 15/01/1918 Master Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Mary Ada South, Of 9, Winifred Terrace, Hendon, Sunderland.
Tepsich J 30 15/01/1918 Boatswain Tower Hill Memorial Born At Constantinople.

War Swallow

War Swallow was a 5,216 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1918 by J. Readhead & Sons, Ltd for the British Government Shipping Controller and managed by Charlton, McAllum & Co. She was sunk on 16 July 1918 by torpedo fired by German submarine UB-50 at position 34° 35' N, 15° 00' E - approximately 72 nautical miles South-West by South of Malta. She was en route from the Tyne to Port Said with a cargo of coal.

War Swallow

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Campbell Kenneth 51 16/07/1918 Able Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Catherine Milne Campbell, Of 34, Church St., Inverness. Born At North Kessock, Ross-Shire.
Douglas George 50 16/07/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Frances Douglas (Nee Ridley), Of 36, Hyde St., South Shields, And The Late John Douglas.
Gibson Thomas 35 16/07/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Sarah Gibson (Nee Miller), Of 8, Cone St., South Shields, And The Late John Gibson.
Middleton James 45 16/07/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Isabella Quigley (Formerly Middleton), Of 88, Stainton St., South Shields. Born At Openshaw, Manchester.
Richer Desire Leon Edouard 36 16/07/1918 Fireman and Trimmer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Desire And Marie Richard (Nee Lecomte), Of Ramee, Guernsey, Channel Islands; Husband Of The Late Mary Ann Richer (Nee Jeff). Born In Guernsey.
Ward Joseph 35 16/07/1918 Second Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Matthew And Sarah Jane Ward; Husband Of Henrietta Ward (Nee Shepherd), Of 22, Dacre St., South Shields. Born At South Shields.
Wilkinson Thomas 38 16/07/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of John And Phoebe Elizabeth Wilkinson; Husband Of Ann Wilkinson (Nee Meakin), Of 21, Weddle Terrace, Green Lane, Tyne Dock, Co. Durham. Born At West Pelton, Co. Durham.

Warilda

Warilda was a 7,713 GRT steam passenger/cargo ship (ref) completed in 1912 by W. Beardmore & Co., Ltd. for Adelaide Steamship Co. Ltd. She was sunk on 3 August 1918 by torpedo fired by German submarine UC-49 at position 50° 10' N, 00° 13' W - approximately 32 nautical miles South-South-West of the Owers Light Vessel. She was en route from Le Havre to Southampton carrying casualties.

Warilda

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Courtney Alfred Henry 28 03/08/1918 Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of William And Martha Courtney, Of 103, St. Andrew S Rd., Southampton; Husband Of Mabel Courtney, Of 26, Weymouth Terrace, Western Shore, Southampton.
Harris Victor 30 03/08/1918 Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Eliza Ann Harris And The Late Charles E. C. Harris; Husband Of Ethel Minnie Harris (Nee Wyatt), Of 78, Clifford St., Southampton. Born At Southampton.
Jordan Edward 37 03/08/1918 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Alice Jordan And The Late Edward Homer Jordan; Husband Of Gertrude Jordan (Nee Bubb), Of 26, Rochester St., Northam, Southampton. Born At Southampton.
Maidment Frederick George 31 03/08/1918 Greaser Tower Hill Memorial Son Of George And Emily Edith Maidment (Nee West), Of Pook S Green, Marchwood, Southampton.
Milne John 24 03/08/1918 Third Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of George And Barbara Milne (Nee Munro), Of 7, Anderson S Rd., Southampton.
Newnham Bernard George 41 03/08/1918 Saloon Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Mary Elizabeth Newnham, And The Late George William Newnham; Husband Of Annie Elizabeth Newnham (Nee Plascott), Of 33, Northbrook Rd., Southampton. Born At Southampton.
Phillips Douglas William 21 03/08/1918 Third Cook Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Ernest William And Agnes Phillips (Nee Hayden), Of 1, Myrtle Cottage, Heath Rd., Sandown, Isle Of Wight. Born At Newchurch, Isle Of Wight.

Warnow

Warnow was a 1,622 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1883 by J. Readhead & Co. for F.Rahtkens & Co. as John Readhead. At the time of her loss she was owned by Warnow Steamship Co. Ltd., renamed Warnow and managed by J. Mitchell & Sons. She was sunk on 2 May 1917 by torpedo fired by German submarine UC-48 at position 50° 30' N, 05° 10' W - approximately 6 nautical miles West of Trevose Head. She was en route from Penarth to an unknown destination with a cargo of railway material.

Warnow
Warnow

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Anderson Joseph 45 02/05/1917 Master Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Frances Mary Anderson, Of 7, Campfield Rd., Camphill, Broughty Ferry, Forfarshire.
Borg Vincent 65 02/05/1917 Ship s Cook Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late Rosario And Rosa Borg; Husband Of Marianna Borg (Nee Gellee), Of 4, Sda Gregale, Senglea, Malta. Born At Valetta, Malta.
Burrell Ernest Arthur 55 02/05/1917 Second Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of The Late James And Elizabeth Burrell; Husband Of Alice Maud Burrell (Nee Lapsley), Of 18, Grant Avenue, Liverpool. Born In London.
Eglit John. 20 02/05/1917 Sailor Tower Hill Memorial Born At Riga.
Flett David Henry 35 02/05/1917 First Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Husband Of Sarah Flett (Nee Starker), Of 34, Milton St., South Shields. Born At North Shields.
Gallagher Joseph 16 02/05/1917 Mess Room Steward Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Hugh And Annie Gallagher (Nee Chappell), Of 24, Percy St., Cwmbwrla, Swansea.
Hasan Saleh 02/05/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Johnston George 21 02/05/1917 Second Mate Tower Hill Memorial Son Of George Bisset And Elizabeth Johnston (Nee Orr), Of 94, Eagleholm St., Glasgow. Born At Govan.
Labonte Joseph 38 02/05/1917 Boatswain Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Louis Elis And Alice Labonte; Husband Of Ethel Adelaide Labonte (Nee Stephens), Of 8, Carnarvon Terrace, Caerau, Bridgend. Born At Port Louis, Mauritius.
Muhammad Raunaq 02/05/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Mules Ivor William 17 02/05/1917 Ordinary Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of John Thomas And Emily Louisa Mules (Nee Wellings), Of 14, Maughan Terrace, Penarth, Glam.
Norman William Richard 18 02/05/1917 Ordinary Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of William Jenkins Norman And Margaret Norman (Nee Williams), Of 29A, Old Orchard St., Swansea.
Saleh Ali 02/05/1917 Fireman and Trimmer Bombay 1914-1918 Memorial, Mumbai
Storey Francis A. 46 02/05/1917 Able Seaman Tower Hill Memorial Born At North Shields.

Warren

Warren was a 3,712 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1899 by W. Pickersgill & Sons for J.Chambers & Co. as Hornby Castle. From 1915 she was owned by Warren Steamship Co. Ltd., renamed Warren and managed by A. D. Axarlis. She was sunk on 1 April 1917 by torpedo fired by German submarine UC-38 at position 41° 51' N, 11° 22' E - approximately 20 nautical miles South-West of Civitavecchia. She was en route from Karachi to La Spezia with grain and a general cargo.

Warren

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Bees Thomas 28 01/04/1917 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial (Served As Kelly). Son Of Mary Hannah Morris (Formerly Bees), Of 50, Granville St., Barton Hill, Bristol, And The Late Matthew Bees.
Kortlang Derk 25 01/04/1917 Chief Donkeyman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Jan Evert Kortlang, Of Wyk B, No. 87, Velp, Near Rheden, Netherlands. Born In Holland.
Molloy Hugh 32 01/04/1917 Fireman Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Hugh Molloy, Of Straboy, Glenties, Co. Donegal, And The Late Fanny Molloy. Born At Glenties. Co. Donegal.

Warrior

Warrior was a 3,674 GRT steam cargo ship completed in 1901 by T. Turnbull & Son for themselves. From 1911 she was owned by Thos. Turnbull & Son Shipping Co. Ltd. and managed by T. Turnbull & Son. She sank on 21 April 1917 after striking a mine laid by German submarine UC-37 approximately 7 nautical miles North-East of the Fratelli Rocks, Tunisia. She was en route from Cardiff to Alexandria with a cargo of coal.

Warrior

Casualties

Surname Forename Age Honours/
Awards		 D.O.D Rank Cemetery/
Memorial		 Grave Ref. Additional Information
Newman Harold Percy 35 21/04/1917 First Engineer Tower Hill Memorial Son Of Charles Robert And Anne Grace Newman (Nee Durie), Of 31, Rawden Place, Cardiff. Born At Great Yarmouth.

Website designed and coded by Brian Watson using PHP, HTML & CSS.
I can be contacted via Feedback